Jamestown Pie Company

excellent bumbleberry pie, they have one with peach too! whole pies, or by the slice.

We had the key lime and strawberry rhubarb pies. Both were great.

Delicious dessert pies. And the pizza is great. Seamed like NY style. Thin crust and large slices.

Excellent pizza and sandwiches! Close to the Jamestown settlement. Thanks for the delicious food!

Jamestown pie company is the absolute best dining experience Williamsburg has to offer. If you go in the summer you can dine outside using there picnic tables. If eating outside is not your thing take the food home and eat like a king in private. If you want the food and feel a little lazy order it by phone and have it delivered.....it's all awesome! They have fresh baked pies that will make your mouth water for months! Bottom line is if your looking for a wonderful place to take the family to then look no further than the Jamestown pie company!

This place is great pecan is delicious not as sweet as a traditional pecan pie which I like

I pulled over on an impulse because this adorable roadside pie shop looked just like the one from The Office. I got an Italian sub, which was delicious and a key lime pie, it was ok. Glad I stopped, cute place!

The crust on the pies were delicious and buttery. I had a blueberry pie that tasted fresh and my with had a boiled peanut pecan pie (not sure what it actually was, but that's what it tasted like). She said she had never had a pie like it before and it was good. She wouldn't order it again though. We also had their artichoke pizza and Chesapeake bay pizza. Both were very good and we loved the amount of garlic on the artichoke (lots). Can't wait to try more of their pies!

It's 75 degrees out, sunny, and you're sitting on a picnic table bench eating a personal-sized strawberry-peach pie in the shade while watching native butterflies flutter around. There's nothing complicated or strange about pie and they make a good one, too. This is a place of no embarrassment. It's easy to spot, there is ample parking, and you can people/car watch as the world goes by.

Great pie and pot pie but I'm sure about the pizza it could be frozen

Best pecan pie I've ever had. Very great service as well.

Small building so it's just take out, but oh so good. Worth the stop.

Friendly customer service and delicious pot pies

The only thing that would make this better would be a restroom facility. And maybe a small pavilion in case of rain for people who wanted to stop and eat their luscious pie on site. My first time there, I had an individual strawberry-peach pie. It was sunny out, perfect temperature, and add to that shade and butterflies playing around the edge of the outdoor seating area, it was like a perfect taste of heaven. It looks like the majority/all business is take out as it is counter order and go, but I could see their pies as the base of a wonderful family picnic.

Pretty damn good apple pie!

Amazing pies! We got chocolate pecan, traditional pecan, key lime, and BlackBerry peach. They were so good! The owners were fantastic and so friendly! I loved to find out they ship! Very reasonably priced as well!

My Husband & I stopped in for the first time yesterday, which was a beautiful 72-degree January day. The owner was as kind as he could be, & we ordered several items to take home, but enjoyed the baklava, which was fantastic, while sitting outside on the patio watching the birds.Since we had never been here before, we ordered several tarts & pie slices to share at home until we could decide which ones to order as entire pies. Which turned out to be a terrible idea b/c we couldn't narrow it down: they were ALL FABULOUS! The Key-Lime pie was good. The Bumble-berry & Chocolate-Pecan pie was my Husband's favorite; & the Chocolate-Pecan & Coconut pie were by far my favorite! They were absolutely to-die-for delicious! We also got a jar of Bumble-berry (blueberry, raspberry, & blackberry) jam. This is our new favorite go-to place for pie's (which is my personal guilty-pleasure!). The prices are very reasonable, & we will DEFINITELY be back for more... Often. Yum...😋

This little shop has the tastiest pies. The owner is very friendly also. We wanted to try different kinds and every one of them turned out to be delicious. If you are out of state I would recommend peanut pie.

Strawberry rhubarb pie! I think if you gave them a recipe, they would make the pie! INCREDIBLE!

very disappointed while I do think they have potential it was a waste of 20no where near enough cheese literally big bald spots all the way aroundand the supposed "Italian "sausage was at best thin slices of kielbasa that really just looked and tasted like mini baloagne I do appreciate that they were open as I was hungry but what a let down from their rating on hereis it that the population has forgotten what good authentic pizza is or did I just the lucky distinction of getting screw up of the day?wont go back unless they offer to make it rightlike I said they have potential that's why it was such a let down

Loved this place. A mandatory hole-in-wall food stop for locals, tourists, or anyone just passing through. Their motto is "Because Round Food is Good Food" (and it would make me round, if I lived closer, because I'd be eating there everyday). The Arno pizza was very good, but their Pot Pies are dynamite. We had the Au Gratin Pot Pie. The crust was amazing and the filling was super rich and creamy with shrimp, scallops, and crab. It's as if Homey comfort food met seafood delight. Another must have is their Chocolate Pecan Pie. It's like biting into a super-gooey chocolate chip cookie. SO GOOD! (The bumbleberry pie is also great; we recommend getting 3-4 smaller pies so you can try different kinds).Note: check out their website and call ahead, if you can. The pot pies take a little while to bake, so if you're in a rush you might need to plan accordingly. Also they don't have indoor seating (so if it's not a nice day, you may want to take it to-go anyway).

The pumpkin pie's crust was RAW and the filling was bland. For the price you are paying, you should expect the pie crust to be baked correctly!

Great pizzas and yummy sandwiches. Had the Tuscan and Sicilian pizzas, both tasted great. Recommend the Dagwood sandwich.

They make the best baklava!

I cannot speak to the pies but they should probably not offer sandwiches. We waited a good 15-20 min for 1 sub. If you are going there stick to pies as that is their forte.

Simply amazing food. Cajun pie is to die for

Came in town for Ironman 70.3 race and this place did not disappoint in the pie department and carb loading! You get what you pay for and I'd pay over and over for their pie because it was AMAZING!! You can tell they put a lot of effort in their work, hence I'll pay the money for their work versus some grocery store subpar pie!! Their pie wasn't too sweet or filled with mushy filling; it was just PERFECT! I had the blueberry peach and my husband had the strawberry rhubarb--the singles were large enough to share as a family of 4. The lady at the counter was kind and sweet to my sons--meant a lot. We just saw they take online orders and we know where we'll be having our pies sent from to Kansas City!

My husband and I love the Dagwood hoagie!!

The Baklava was out of this world!

John and I have driven past this place for months and I kept saying I wanted to go but we just kept forgetting to come. Today, we finally made it and its SO worth it! I ordered their turkey pot pie and John got the beef pot pie and these are honestly the most delicious pot pies I've ever had!!! I can't wait to try their dessert pies!!

Swang by for a Father's Day treat and the key lime pie was perfect. Not too tart but still that bite of lime that's great for a summer day. The chocolate pecan was also awesome (if you don't love it you're broke). The man running the place was really nice and just rattled of what was in the case and what he could cut for us. The kids loved the ice cream and I know he threw an extra scoop on for them. If you are in the area definitely seeing by, maybe grab a slice to eat while you ride the ferry.

The pies are good but the blueberry peach was really bland. Crust is flaky though! The pizza was really good. Never had anything like it before. It was a little hard to eat from all the toppings and the crust wasn't very supportive but it was tasty.

Their pies are wonderful and the pizza sauce is amazing!

Nice people. Excellent pies.

We stopped in today because of the amazing reviews. The food was phenomenal! We had a sausage and pepperoni pizza and an Italian! Well worth it. No indoor seating but it was cool enough to sit outside. Great little place. We will absolutely come again when visiting!

We stopped by for a late lunch after our day at the Jamestown settlement. We had a large Sicilian which was very good. The cheese fries were great too but we had to eat fast as the weather outdoors made the melted mozzarella coagulate real fast. The girl behind the counter was very friendly. Will definitely be back.

We love getting the chicken pot pie a few times a month for dinner for our family. Affordable and delicious. When family comes in town- they always want it!

I just got a large pepperoni pizza and it was delicious. Haven't had a dessert pie from them in a year or so but they're good too.